💬
[E7326] The text emphasizes that 'there are no positive limitations to the expansion of individual credit,' highlighting the inherent inability of monetary authorities to constrain credit creation at the individual level. This structural feature means credit cycles will inevitably overshoot, creating bubbles whose eventual deflation is sudden and severe — 'as with a child's balloon, it will deflate suddenly.'
commentary · 2025-12-06
🟢
[E7321] Central banks face fundamental limitations in controlling credit expansion and speculation due to the 'shotgun not rifle' problem — they cannot simultaneously target price stability and asset price stability with one policy instrument. While somewhat different monetary policy could have moderated historical booms, it cannot eliminate credit cycles entirely. Bank of England made 24 discount rate changes in 1873 to avoid crisis while others failed.
supporting · 2025-12-06
🟢
[E7319] Financial crises follow a predictable sequence: economic shock → expansion → boom → euphoria → distress → panic → crash. Lord Overstone described this as 'quiescence, improvement, confidence, prosperity, excitement, overtrading, CONVULSION, pressure, stagnation.' This biological regularity in financial cycles is demonstrated across centuries of historical examples from tulipmania to the 2008 crisis.
supporting · 2025-12-06
🟢
[E7320] Asset price bubbles create symmetrical feedback loops to economic activity through wealth effects — rising prices increase household consumption and business investment, while declining prices produce the reverse. The Japanese bubble (1980s-1990s) with the Nikkei declining 80% from 40,000 to 8,000 (1990-2002) demonstrates these wealth effect feedback loops and their devastating economic consequences.
supporting · 2025-12-06
🟢
[E7325] Central bank warnings about asset price bubbles are historically ineffective. Greenspan's December 1996 'irrational exuberance' comment had no lasting impact on stock prices, and similar warnings throughout history have failed to dampen speculative sentiment. The timing problem means warnings may even precipitate crashes, while moral hazard from bailouts encourages future risky behavior.
supporting · 2025-12-06